Tuesday, 8 September 2026

Eight Fairies, Clothing and the Gaze

 




While the recent controversy over women’s presence in public spaces and their clothing, following remarks by Muslim religious leader Kanthapuram, continues to provoke debate, I was reminded of a painting I encountered recently: Nguyễn Thanh Bình’s Eight Fairies (2013).
The painting depicts eight women. One sits slightly apart from the others, almost as though waiting for something to wear, while the remaining seven appear gathered around a large piece of white cloth. What interested me particularly was the artist’s treatment of the body. The women’s torsos are exposed, while much of their lower bodies disappears beneath the white fabric.
The image made me think about how differently societies construct modesty and the sexual gaze. Anyone familiar with contemporary urban Vietnam will have noticed that clothing conventions do not necessarily correspond to those of India. Shorts, short skirts, and dresses that expose much of the legs are commonplace in many Vietnamese cities, while the torso generally remains covered in everyday public life. What one culture considers provocative may therefore appear entirely ordinary in another.
This makes Bình’s painting particularly interesting to me. By exposing the torsos while allowing the legs to disappear beneath the cloth, the painting seems to unsettle our habitual assumptions about which parts of the body acquire sexual significance. The naked body does not carry a universal meaning independent of culture; societies teach us where to look, what to conceal and, consequently, what to sexualise.
I am neither a scholar of sexuality nor of eroticism. In fact, as an artist, I have often found the human body aesthetically less interesting than the cultural meanings constructed around it. Yet I confronted this question in my own work in 2010, while painting a Pietà as part of an enquiry into the body, persecution, gender, and cloth. I changed Jesus's gender from male to female. This seemingly simple change forced me to confront the female breast in several overlapping ways: as part of the human anatomy, as a source of nourishment for a child, and as a part of the body culturally conditioned to attract a sexual gaze. The question, therefore, was not simply whether the body should be covered, but how the gaze itself had been culturally produced. The mother-child relationship is central to the Pietà, and I did not want the exposed torso of a female Jesus to divert attention from that relationship by introducing an unintended sexual reading. I therefore chose to cover her torso while leaving her legs exposed.
This brings me back to Kanthapuram and the present controversy. Eight Fairies suggests a question worth considering: Does covering the body eliminate the sexual gaze, or can elaborate regimes of concealment actually intensify the meanings attached to what is concealed?
Perhaps modesty cannot finally be manufactured by prescribing how much of a woman's body must disappear beneath cloth. When a society repeatedly marks particular parts of the female body as things that must be hidden, it may inadvertently make those very parts objects of heightened sexual attention.
In that sense, the eight fairies offer an interesting lesson. Freedom in clothing does not necessarily produce the sexual gaze; sometimes it is the culture of compulsory concealment that teaches the gaze where to look. And that is precisely why the freedom to decide what to wear should belong to the woman herself.

No comments:

Post a Comment